OreoReviewRandom
The Board

Caramel Apple Pie

November 19, 2025

  • limited edition
  • thanksgiving pack
Alex6/10
Matti7/10

The best thing in the pack, which by this point was not a high bar.

It is a caramel apple sucker in Oreo form - spot on, almost impressive. Very heavy on the apple, in a green, sour, Jolly Rancher direction rather than anything that ever grew on a tree. There’s a real candy-like quality to it that makes eating more than one hard work.

I originally called it an eight. That was wrong, and I said so on camera: I was grading it against the disasters sitting next to it rather than against Oreos generally. Marked down to a six.

I’d eat it. I wouldn’t buy it.

On camera

Watch on YouTube

Your turn

No account, no email. One rating per browser - change it whenever you like.